PIES
Criminal Baking Company makes pies in small batches, from scratch, just for you! We accept orders each month only until our baking calendar is full, so be sure to contact us as far in advance as possible to ensure booking availability. Use the button at the bottom of this page to place pie orders, request a quote, or to contact us with questions.
ORDERING A PIE IS AS EASY AS 1 2 3 4 5
STEP 1 - CHOOSE A CRUST
STEP 2 - CHOOSE A FLAVOR
STEP 3 - CHOOSE A SIZE/TYPE
Note: vegan only available in fruit flavors w/ crumb top
STEP 4 - CLICK BUTTON BELOW TO PLACE PIE YOUR PIE ORDER
- flaky pastry
- traditional shortbread crust (available gluten-free)
- graham cookie
- ginger cookie
- chocolate cookie
- oat/nut/seed blend (vegan and gluten-free)
- galettes (available for fresh fruit fillings only)
STEP 2 - CHOOSE A FLAVOR
- Sweet Potato
- Apple Crumb
- Pumpkin
- Black & Blue Berry Crumb
- Black Forest (cherry, chocolate, whipped cream)
- Bourbon Banana Cream
- Maple Pecan Pie
- Cherry Pecan Crumb
- Chocolate Cream
- Coconut Cream
- Key Lime w/ Raspberry Drizzle
- Maple Mixed Nut (similar to a pecan pie without corn syrup, plus lots of other nuts too!)
- Meyer Lemon Custard & Cream
- Peanut Butter Chocolate
- S'Mores Pie (graham cracker crust, dark chocolate center, toasted marshmallow top)
- Shaker Lemon
- Autumn Fruit Cobbler
- Tart Cherry Crumb
- Triple Chocolate Cream
- Toasted Walnut Pie
STEP 3 - CHOOSE A SIZE/TYPE
- 9" in a pie tin $35
- 9.5" in a glass deep dish $38 + refundable $8 dish deposit (Note: glass dish not available for Thanksgiving.)
- Mini Pies $5 each (minimum order of 6)
- Mini Tarts $4 each (minimum order of 6)
- Tiny Tarts $2.50 each (minimum order of 6)
- Hand Pies $5 each (minimum order of 6)
- Jar Pies Small $4 or Large $5 each (minimum order of 6)
Note: vegan only available in fruit flavors w/ crumb top
STEP 4 - CLICK BUTTON BELOW TO PLACE PIE YOUR PIE ORDER
STEP 5 - CONFIRM & PAY
We will contact you to confirm your order and to accept payment. All pie orders must be pre-paid. We accept orders each month only until our baking calendar is full, so be sure to contact us as far in advance as possible to ensure booking availability. Use the button above to place pie orders, request a quote, or to contact us with questions.
We will contact you to confirm your order and to accept payment. All pie orders must be pre-paid. We accept orders each month only until our baking calendar is full, so be sure to contact us as far in advance as possible to ensure booking availability. Use the button above to place pie orders, request a quote, or to contact us with questions.